My Modern Law
  • Home
  • Our Team
    • Billie Tarascio
    • Darin Colburn
    • Kylie Bigelow
    • Don Colburn
    • Henry Alzate
    • Bruce Brown
    • Candice Tully
    • Elizabeth Brooks
    • Katie Martin
    • Amanda Howard
    • Caitlin Lindahl
  • Practice Areas
    • Child Custody
    • Child Support
    • Division of Assets
    • Divorce
    • Marital Agreements
    • Postnuptial Agreement
    • Prenuptial Agreement
    • Separation Agreements
    • Spousal Support
  • Locations
    • Chandler
    • Mesa
    • Peoria
    • Scottsdale
  • Resources
    • Blog
    • Guides
    • Video Resources
    • FAQs
    • Testimonials
    • Family Law Tools
      • Mesa Child Support Calculator
      • Co-Mingled Property Calculator
      • Spousal Maintenance Estimator
  • Contact Us
Click to Call or Text
(480) 649-2905
header-phone
X
Divorce is Scary. We Make it Better.

Same Sex Parents And Legal Paternity in Mesa

Laws regarding same-sex parents are just now beginning to come into focus, particularly when the question of parenthood comes up.

Arizona has long had statutes that automatically presume paternity when there are one of four specific scenarios at work. When a child’s legal parent is in question, these four situations determine who is legally considered the child’s parent.

This can be challenged though. The challenger must prove by clear and convincing evidence that the presumed Father is not the biological Father of the child.

Scenario 1

The presumed father and the mother of the child were married at any time the child was born or within 10 months of the child’s birth. For example, if the parents divorced 10 months before the birth, the presumption still applies. Additionally, if the parents divorced one month after the birth, the presumption also applies.

Scenario 2

Genetic testing affirms at least a 95 percent probability of paternity.

Scenario 3

A birth certificate is signed by the mother and father of a child born out of wedlock.

Scenario 4

A notarized or witnessed statement is signed by both parents acknowledging paternity or separate substantially similar notarized or witnessed statements are signed by both parents acknowledging paternity.

The language of the statute governing this presumption, A.R.S. §25-814(A) is expressly directed at males and the male spouses. Additionally, there is no corresponding statute outlining a presumption of maternity, for example.

When Paternity Means Parenthood

Thus, when the U.S. Supreme Court legalized same-sex marriage in the Obergefell case, a debate began about whether the presumption of paternity should be more broadly interpreted to mean a presumption of parenthood.

This topic was particularly important to same-sex parents because it is not possible for both spouses to be biological parents.   That means that the non-adopted children of same-sex parents are only biologically related to one of the parents.

If the statute were interpreted to same-sex couples, the presumption would tend to protect the non-biological parent spouse.

What The Courts Say About Same-Sex Parents

The Arizona Court of Appeals recently ruled on this issue in the 2016 McLaughlin case. In that case, two women who married in California prior to the Obergefell case, later moved to Arizona. After arriving in Arizona, the women had a child through artificial insemination. After the birth, the women executed identical wills and a joint parenting agreement declaring both were equal parents to the child.

The women eventually filed for divorce.  The biological Mother then sought to prevent her ex-spouse from exercising rights as a parent of the child. The Arizona Supreme Court found that Obergefell mandates that the presumption of paternity statute be applied to same-sex parents.

Thus, the Court held that the non-biological spouse was entitled to the presumption of maternity under the statute.

The Court would have let the biological Mother rebut the legal presumption of maternity if the agreement had not been signed by both parents.

If the Mother had not made the joint agreement, the Court would not have barred her from changing her position. This is a key to the outcome of this case. Without a way to prevent rebuttal, the presumption of maternity to the non-genetic spouse would be meaningless.

Book Now for a $49 Consultation
Sending us information does not create an attorney/client relationship
Mesa Paternity Lawyer
  • Paternity and Maternity Proceedings
  • Same Sex Parents
Get Your Free Step-by-Step Guide to Planning, Executing and Surviving Your Mesa Arizona Divorce
Get Your Free Beginners Local Divorce Guide for Scottsdale
My Modern Law

Arizona Divorce Attorney

Divorce is life changing. Knowledge gives you power. Let’s start by sharing our playbook. Take a look at our library of Q&As, articles, and calculator tools to help you on your journey.

Facebook Twitter Linkedin

My Modern Law

My Modern Law
N/a
SCOTTSDALE
15333 N Pima Road
STE 305

Scottsdale,  AZ  85260
Get Directions
(602) 910-5360Click to Call
MESA
1744 S Val Vista Dr.
STE 205

Mesa,  AZ  85204
Get Directions
(480) 649-2905Click to Call
PEORIA
16165 N 83rd Ave
Suite 200

Peoria,  AZ  85382
Get Directions
Modern Law Proud Member of
© My Modern Law 2019. All rights reserved. Governed by the Arizona rules of professional conduct.
  • Privacy Policy
  • Disclaimer
  • Home
  • Our Team
    ▼
    • Billie Tarascio
    • Darin Colburn
    • Kylie Bigelow
    • Don Colburn
    • Henry Alzate
    • Bruce Brown
    • Candice Tully
    • Elizabeth Brooks
    • Katie Martin
    • Amanda Howard
    • Caitlin Lindahl
  • Practice Areas
    ▼
    • Child Custody
    • Child Support
    • Division of Assets
    • Divorce
    • Marital Agreements
    • Postnuptial Agreement
    • Prenuptial Agreement
    • Separation Agreements
    • Spousal Support
  • Locations
    ▼
    • Chandler
    • Mesa
    • Peoria
    • Scottsdale
  • Resources
    ▼
    • Blog
    • Guides
    • Video Resources
    • FAQs
    • Testimonials
    • Family Law Tools
      ▼
      • Mesa Child Support Calculator
      • Co-Mingled Property Calculator
      • Spousal Maintenance Estimator
  • Contact Us