My Modern Law
  • Home
  • Our Team
    • Billie Tarascio
    • Darin Colburn
    • Kylie Bigelow
    • Don Colburn
    • Henry Alzate
    • Bruce Brown
    • Candice Tully
    • Elizabeth Brooks
    • Katie Martin
    • Amanda Howard
    • Caitlin Lindahl
  • Practice Areas
    • Child Custody
    • Child Support
    • Division of Assets
    • Divorce
    • Marital Agreements
    • Postnuptial Agreement
    • Prenuptial Agreement
    • Separation Agreements
    • Spousal Support
  • Locations
    • Chandler
    • Mesa
    • Peoria
    • Scottsdale
  • Resources
    • Blog
    • Guides
    • Video Resources
    • FAQs
    • Testimonials
    • Family Law Tools
      • Mesa Child Support Calculator
      • Co-Mingled Property Calculator
      • Spousal Maintenance Estimator
  • Contact Us
Click to Call or Text
(480) 649-2905
header-phone
X
Divorce is Scary. We Make it Better

Who has legal decision making rights (custody) of a child born to unwed parents in Arizona?

Custody Custody Q&As Father's Rights Paternity Uncategorized

Who has legal decision making rights (custody) of a child born to unwed parents in Arizona?

The question of whether unmarried parents have joint legal decision-making by default is undecided. The only Arizona statute on the subject is a criminal statute regarding custodial interference that provides, for the purposes of Criminal Law only, an unwed mother is the legal custodian until paternity is established and custody or access is determined by a court. A.R.S. §13-1302.

Some attorneys claim this statute stands for the proposition that unwed mothers have superior legal decision-making rights. This is true if paternity has not been established. However, once paternity is established, nothing in the Arizona Family Law statutes (Title 25) grants an unwed mother superior legal decision-making rights. If paternity has been established for an unwed father, but there have been no legal decision-making (custody) proceedings or orders, an unwed mother has the upper hand for the purposes of custodial interference, but not necessarily for legal decision-making.

For example, five year old Joe was born to unmarried parents and lives primarily with his father. Joe sees his mother about once a month because she lives in California. Joe’s father wants to put him in a charter school focusing on language immersion and his mother is opposed. In my opinion, the Criminal Custodial Interference statute does not apply to this scenario as there are no custodial interference issues. Both parents are legally entitled to enroll the child in school and make the decision of where Joe should attend school. If the parents cannot agree, they need to go to court to establish legal decision-making, along with parenting time and child support. Even if the court grants joint legal decision-making, the court will then hear from both mother and father regarding the school issue and ultimately make the decision.

Another common situation is when a child of unwed parents receives a diagnosis, such as ADHD. The mother may want one type of treatment and the father may disagree. Since both parents have the legal authority to authorize treatment, a court would have to determine who has legal decision-making and whether or not there is a final decision maker. It is unlikely an unwed mother has superior legal decision-making authority in this situation. That said, if paternity has not been established and an unwed father has not been involved with the parenting of the child, and subsequently claims authority and rights, the Criminal Custodial Interference Statute likely applies, and an unwed mother will have superior authority.

The above is my opinion and analysis based on experience in Arizona Family Courts, but no clear rule exists on the subject. It is important for unmarried parents to file with the Family Court in order to establish rights, duties and responsibilities. When everyone understands what is expected and their obligations, fewer disagreements occur. For help establishing your custodial rights, contact us today at 480-649-2905.

 

 

Book Now for a $49 Consultation
Sending us information does not create an attorney/client relationship
Categories
  • About Us/Announcements
  • Adoption
  • Alimony/Spousal Maintenance
  • Arizona Divorce News
  • Child Support
  • Child Support Q&As
  • Consultations
  • Custody
  • Custody Documents
  • Custody Q&As
  • Disclosure
  • Disclosures and Discovery
  • Divorce
  • Divorce Costs
  • Divorce Q&As
  • Divorce Stories
  • Documents
  • Drug Use and Violence
  • Enforcement
  • Enforcement
  • Experts
  • FAQs
  • Father's Rights
  • Finding An Attorney
  • Grandparents and Third Party Custody
  • Guardianship
  • Hidden Money and Debt
  • In The News
  • Infographics
  • Managing Divorce Costs
  • Modification
  • Modification
  • My Story
  • News
  • Parenting Time
  • Paternity
  • Personal
  • Practical Advice
  • Practice Tips
  • Prenuptial Agreements
  • Preparation
  • Property Division
  • Property Documents
  • Property Q&As
  • Property Settlement
  • Protection
  • Q&As
  • Relocation
  • Spousal Maintenance Documents
  • Spousal Maintenance Q&As
  • Taxes, Business and Retirement
  • Teens and Custody
  • Termination of Rights
  • Uncategorized
  • Video
  • Webinars
  • Wellness News
My Modern Law

Arizona Divorce Attorney

Divorce is life changing. Knowledge gives you power. Let’s start by sharing our playbook. Take a look at our library of Q&As, articles, and calculator tools to help you on your journey.

Facebook Twitter Linkedin

My Modern Law

My Modern Law
N/a
SCOTTSDALE
15333 N Pima Road
STE 305

Scottsdale,  AZ  85260
Get Directions
(602) 910-5360Click to Call
MESA
1744 S Val Vista Dr.
STE 205

Mesa,  AZ  85204
Get Directions
(480) 649-2905Click to Call
PEORIA
16165 N 83rd Ave
Suite 200

Peoria,  AZ  85382
Get Directions
(623) 377-4855Click to Call
Modern Law Proud Member of
© My Modern Law 2019. All rights reserved. Governed by the Arizona rules of professional conduct.
  • Privacy Policy
  • Disclaimer
  • Home
  • Our Team
    ▼
    • Billie Tarascio
    • Darin Colburn
    • Kylie Bigelow
    • Don Colburn
    • Henry Alzate
    • Bruce Brown
    • Candice Tully
    • Elizabeth Brooks
    • Katie Martin
    • Amanda Howard
    • Caitlin Lindahl
  • Practice Areas
    ▼
    • Child Custody
    • Child Support
    • Division of Assets
    • Divorce
    • Marital Agreements
    • Postnuptial Agreement
    • Prenuptial Agreement
    • Separation Agreements
    • Spousal Support
  • Locations
    ▼
    • Chandler
    • Mesa
    • Peoria
    • Scottsdale
  • Resources
    ▼
    • Blog
    • Guides
    • Video Resources
    • FAQs
    • Testimonials
    • Family Law Tools
      ▼
      • Mesa Child Support Calculator
      • Co-Mingled Property Calculator
      • Spousal Maintenance Estimator
  • Contact Us